Hi
@alfredus when you say (except Simpson) what is your recommended Simpson synthetic?
I got a 24mm Maggard as a decent cheap entry level to pilot but found it too soft and floppy, perhaps a tried and tested quality one will change my mind.
i had a Chubby 2 Synthetic and it is the closest synthetic to a natural hair brush...it is very dense and has some decent backbone, but you can lather very well...similar to a good 2-band badger.
But it still doesn't have the "soul" of a badger, so I passed it on. I use my synthetic only for traveling and for that I prefer the Muhle/EJ XL - as it is less dense and needs less time/work to create a decent lather. I am also not a fan of the Chubby 2 handle, as it is too small for my paws...
But if you are looking for a synthetic, that comes close to a natural hair/badger brush, those are the only ones I have found so far.
Although I haven't tried out the various new knots from Yaqi and the like, I am quiet certain, that they are all...too different from badgers for me to like (judging from the pics and reviews).
If you are looking for a synthetic for practical reasons (like me travel etc.) or for moral reasons, I would strongly suggests getting both of those (Chubby 2 synth, Muhle/EJ XL )in and be done with it...
Else I would highly recommend going the badger route and be done with it as well. If you think, you are saving money...you will buy numerous synthetics, get a decent badger, fall in love and all that money on synthetics will be wasted (speaking of course from personal experince)
